Chimney Starters vs Electric Starters for Charcoal Barbecues: Which is Better?

When it comes to starting a charcoal barbecue, there are two main methods: chimney starters and electric starters. Both options have their benefits and drawbacks, and the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific needs.

Chimney Starters vs Electric Starters for Charcoal Barbecues: Which is Better?

Chimney starters are a popular choice for charcoal bbq enthusiasts. They are simple in design and function, consisting of a hollow metal tube with a grate at the bottom where the charcoal is placed. The user then crumples up some newspaper, slides it into the bottom of the chimney, and lights it. The heat from the paper ignites the charcoal, which gradually works its way up the chimney. Once the charcoal is hot and ashy, it can be poured into the grill. One advantage of chimney starters is that they do not require electricity, making them a great option for outdoor use or in a power outage. However, they can take a bit longer to heat up than electric starters, and require some extra effort to get the fire started.

Electric starters, on the other hand, are a more modern solution. They look similar to a heating coil, and function similarly as well. A user simply nestles the electric starter into the charcoal and plugs it in. In just a few minutes, the charcoal will be hot and ready to use. Electric starters are a great option for those who want to get their barbecue going quickly and easily. However, they do require access to electricity, which may not always be possible or convenient. Additionally, they can be more expensive to purchase upfront than chimney starters.

Chimney Starters: Definition and How They Work

If you’re a grilling enthusiast, you’ve probably heard of a chimney starter as a primary tool for starting your barbecue grill. A chimney starter is a metal cylinder that helps ignite charcoal briquettes or natural lump charcoal, making it an excellent and efficient method of starting your fire.

Chimney starters come in different sizes, but the most common models hold enough charcoal to accommodate most grilling needs. You fill the chimney starter with charcoal and place a sheet of newspaper or fire starter in the bottom section of the chimney. Once lit, the fire starter or the newspaper ignites and creates a heat source to set the charcoal burning. The design of the chimney starter maximizes airflow by allowing the hot air to rise and draw oxygen-rich air through the bottom, which helps start the charcoal significantly faster than other methods.

One benefit of using a chimney starter is that it avoids the need for lighter fluid, which gives your food a chemical taste, and is also hazardous to your health and the environment. Chimney starters are designed to work with natural lump charcoal, hardwood, or briquettes, making it easier to achieve the right temperature on your grill without an aftertaste.

Moreover, using a chimney starter is a straightforward process that only requires a few minutes of preparation. A chimney starter functions like a mini fireplace, so you should only use one outdoors and place it on a heat resistance surface. When the charcoal ash at the top of the chimney turns grey, you can pour the coals into the grill and start cooking!

In summary, chimney starters provide a safe and efficient way to ignite charcoal briquettes or natural lump charcoal for your grill. Using a chimney starter eliminates any chemical tastes on your food and avoids the hazards of lighter fluid while also being easy to use.

Electric Starters: Definition and How They Work

If you’re looking for an easier way to start your charcoal grill, electric starters might be just what you need. An electric starter is a small, handheld tool designed to ignite charcoal briquettes quickly and easily. It consists of a metal coil that heats up when plugged into an electrical outlet. The heat from the coil is then transferred to the charcoal, which slowly begins to light up.

Here’s how electric starters work:

  1. Place the electric starter on top of the pile of briquettes in your grill.
  2. Plug the starter into a nearby electrical outlet.
  3. Wait a few minutes until the briquettes start to turn gray and ash over.
  4. Unplug the starter and remove it from the grill.
  5. Use a pair of tongs to spread out the briquettes evenly across the grill grates.

Electric starters are a great option for those who want a fast, hassle-free way to start their charcoal grill. They eliminate the need for lighter fluid, which can be messy and sometimes leave a chemical taste on your food. Additionally, electric starters are much safer than other ignition methods, as there is no open flame involved.

However, there are some drawbacks that you should be aware of. Electric starters can take a few minutes longer to get your grill going compared to chimney starters – around 10-15 minutes on average. They also require access to a power outlet, which can be a challenge if you’re grilling in a remote location without electricity.

Despite these minor downsides, electric starters are a reliable and efficient way to get your charcoal grill up and running quickly. With a bit of practice, you can use them to achieve perfectly lit, evenly cooked food every time.

Comparison of Chimney Starters and Electric Starters

When it comes to lighting up a charcoal barbecue, there are two main options: chimney starters and electric starters. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, depending on the user’s preferences and situation.

Chimney Starters

Chimney starters are metal cylinders with a grate at the bottom and a handle at the top. They work by filling the top with charcoal, crumpled paper or other fuel at the bottom, and then lighting the fuel. As the fuel burns, it heats the charcoal above it, which gradually catches fire. The hot, glowing embers can be poured out onto the grill once they’re evenly lit.

Advantages of Chimney Starters:

  • They’re simple and inexpensive.
  • They don’t require electricity.
  • They heat charcoal evenly and quickly.
  • They’re environmentally friendly, as they don’t require lighter fluid.

Disadvantages of Chimney Starters:

  • They require some patience and effort to get started.
  • They can be dangerous if not handled properly.
  • The handles can get hot during use.

Electric Starters

Electric starters are long, wand-like tools that plug into an outlet. They have a heating element at the end that’s inserted into the charcoal and turned on. The heat from the element ignites the charcoal, which can then be spread out once they’re evenly lit.

Advantages of Electric Starters:

  • They’re very easy to use.
  • They don’t require any other fuel besides electricity.
  • They’re safer than chimney starters since they don’t involve flames or hot metal.
  • They’re faster than chimney starters, providing the charcoal with very high heat.

Disadvantages of Electric Starters:

  • They can be more expensive than chimney starters.
  • They’re dependent on electricity.
  • They can wear out quickly if not used properly.

In conclusion, both chimney starters and electric starters have their pros and cons. Chimney starters are a traditional and inexpensive option for those who don’t mind waiting a few minutes for their coals to light. Electric starters are a more convenient and faster method, but they can be more expensive and require an outlet. Ultimately, it’s up to the user to decide which option suits their needs best.

Advantages of Using Chimney Starters

When it comes to starting a charcoal barbecue, there are a few methods to choose from, but one method that stands out, in particular, is using a chimney starter. While electric starters have their benefits, there are a few advantages to using chimney starters that make them a preferred and standard method among many BBQ enthusiasts. In this section of the article, I’ll discuss some of the benefits of using chimney starters.

1. No Need for Electricity

One of the significant advantages of using chimney starters is that you don’t need electricity to get it started. This makes it an excellent option if you’re hosting an outdoor BBQ party and don’t have access to an electrical outlet. All you need is some newspaper, firelighters, and charcoal, and you’re good to go. You’ll be able to enjoy a perfect BBQ regardless of where you are or what the conditions are.

2. Fast and Efficient

Another benefit of using a chimney starter is that it is fast and efficient. Once you get the charcoal going, within 10-15 minutes, you should be ready to start preparing your food. This method is quicker than other traditional methods like lighter fluid, which can take up to 30 minutes or more. The high heat created in the chimney starter helps to quickly ignite the charcoal evenly, making it the perfect method for those who are impatient or want to have a quick cookout.

3. Healthier Option

Unlike lighter fluid, which can produce harmful chemicals, the chimney starter method is a healthier option. You won’t have to worry about any dangerous chemicals getting into your food, which is essential if you’re cooking for family or friends. It also makes the charcoal taste better since there is no chemical residue to affect its flavor.

4. Cost-Effective

Finally, using a chimney starter is cost-effective when compared to other starting methods. It allows you to save your budget and channel the savings elsewhere, like investing in high-quality meat or charcoal. Additionally, it is a one-time investment that can last you multiple seasons if well maintained.

In conclusion, using a chimney starter over electric starters comes with several advantages. It’s a simpler, healthier, and more cost-effective method that saves time and doesn’t require electricity. The only downside could be the smoke produced, but if you set your chimney in the right place, that shouldn’t be much of an issue.

Advantages of Using Electric Starters

One of the main advantages of using electric starters for charcoal barbecues is that they are quick and easy to use. Electric starters allow you to start your charcoal grill in just a few minutes without the need for lighter fluid or other accelerants. This not only saves time, but eliminates the risk of accidentally starting a fire or making your food taste like lighter fluid.

Electric starters are also more environmentally friendly than using lighter fluid. Using lighter fluid can release harmful chemicals into the air which contribute to air pollution and can be detrimental to your health. Electric starters, on the other hand, don’t emit any harmful gases into the air and are a safer option for you and the environment.

Additionally, electric starters can save you money in the long run. While they may cost more upfront than traditional chimney starters, they are reusable and can last for years with proper care and maintenance. This means you won’t have to continuously purchase lighter fluid or other accelerants, which can add up in cost over time.

Another advantage of using electric starters is that they are more versatile than traditional chimney starters. Electric starters can be used for other types of grills and even for lighting candles or starting fires in a fireplace. This makes them a great investment for anyone who enjoys outdoor cooking or hosting barbecues.

Overall, electric starters are a convenient, environmentally friendly, cost-effective, and versatile option for starting charcoal barbecues. If you’re looking to upgrade your grilling game, consider investing in an electric starter for your next cookout.

Disadvantages of Using Chimney Starters

While chimney starters are a popular tool for lighting charcoal briquettes, they do come with some disadvantages that may not make them the best choice for everyone. Here are some drawbacks to using chimney starters:

1. Requires More Time

Using a chimney starter is not always the quickest method for lighting charcoal. Sometimes it may take longer for the charcoal to light up completely, especially if the weather is cool or windy. This could be frustrating for those who are in a hurry to start their barbecue.

2. Fire Hazard

Chimney starters require an open flame to light the charcoal, which can be a fire hazard if not used properly. It’s important to place the chimney starter on a stable surface and keep it away from anything flammable. This can be a concern if you’re using a chimney starter in a small space or around children.

3. Messy Cleanup

One downside of using a chimney starter is that it can leave a messy residue behind such as ash and charred wood pieces. This can create extra cleanup work once you’re finished grilling. Additionally, the residue can also be a potential health hazard if inhaled in large quantities.

4. Cost

Chimney starters are relatively inexpensive, but they do require the purchase of lighter fluid or other fire-starting materials. This added cost may not make it the most economical option for some individuals, especially if they only grill occasionally.

While chimney starters have their benefits, it’s also necessary to consider the potential drawbacks before deciding whether to use them or not for your charcoal barbecue.

Disadvantages of Using Electric Starters

While electric starters offer convenience and speed when it comes to lighting up your charcoal BBQ, they also have a few disadvantages. Here are some reasons why electric starters may not be the best choice for every grilling situation:

  1. Limited portability: Electric starters require access to a power source, which can be difficult if you’re grilling at a park, camping site, or other outdoor location without electrical outlets. In contrast, chimney starters only require a match or lighter to get the fire going, making them a more portable option.
  2. Risk of damage: The heating element in electric starters can be delicate, which means they may not hold up well if you accidentally drop them or expose them to the elements. This can be frustrating if you need to replace your electric starter frequently, making it a less reliable option in the long term compared to chimney starters.
  3. Increased cost: Electric starters are generally more expensive than chimney starters, which can be frustrating if you’re trying to stick to a budget. Additionally, they can add to your monthly energy bills as they require electricity to function.
  4. Potentially dangerous: Though they may be convenient, electric starters do come with some risks. They can potentially overheat and cause a fire if left unattended, and they are not safe for use in rainy or wet conditions. Chimney starters, on the other hand, are less likely to present any risk even when used in rainy conditions.

While electric starters can be an attractive option for some grillers, it’s important to consider these disadvantages before making a decision. Depending on your grilling setup and personal preferences, a chimney starter may be a better choice in terms of portability, durability, cost, and safety.

Thanks for the clarification. Here’s the section on “Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Chimney Starters and Electric Starters”:

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Chimney Starters and Electric Starters

When it comes to lighting charcoal for your barbeque, it’s important to choose the right starter method that fits your preference, time, budget, and safety. Here are some factors to consider when choosing between chimney starters and electric starters:

  • Speed and Efficiency: Chimney starters generally take longer to start the charcoal, but they tend to be more efficient in lighting the charcoal more evenly. Electric starters, on the other hand, can heat up the charcoal quickly, but they may not distribute heat evenly.
  • Ease of Use: Both chimney starters and electric starters are easy to use, but some people may prefer one over the other. Chimney starters require newspaper or other kindling to get the fire going, while electric starters only require an outlet.
  • Safety: Both starter methods are relatively safe, but chimney starters require more caution during use. Handling hot charcoal, burning paper, and the chimney itself can pose a risk of burns and fire. Electric starters, while simpler to use, come with their own safety concerns such as electrical shock and accidental fires.
  • Flexibility and Portability: Chimney starters come in various sizes, making them flexible for different quantities of charcoal and setups. They are also very portable, easy to store, and usable in places without electricity. Electric starters are limited by their cords and need access to an outlet, making them less flexible and portable.
  • Cost: Chimney starters are generally more affordable than electric starters, but the long-term savings may depend on various factors such as frequency of use, electricity rates, and charcoal quality.

Ultimately, the choice between chimney starters and electric starters boils down to your personal preference, budget, and situation. For those seeking a simple, affordable, and portable solution, chimney starters may be the way to go. For those looking for quicker and more convenient lighting with less mess and physical effort, electric starters may be the better choice.

Safety Measures When Using Chimney Starters and Electric Starters

As with any method of lighting a BBQ, there are potential safety risks involved when using chimney starters and electric starters. However, if proper precautions are taken, these risks can be minimized significantly. Here are some key safety measures to keep in mind when using either of these methods:

  • Always use gloves or tongs to handle hot coals, and never touch them with your bare hands.
  • Keep children and pets away from the barbecue while it’s lit and during the cooking process.
  • Place the chimney starter or electric starter on a level, stable surface that isn’t flammable. Avoid using grass or uneven surfaces, and keep it away from trees or other structures.
  • When using a chimney starter, never add lighter fluid or any other flammable liquids to the coals. This can cause a dangerous flare-up.
  • When using an electric starter, ensure that the cord is out of the way and won’t be tripped over. Don’t leave the electric starter unattended.
  • Allow the coals to fully ignite and turn white before spreading them out in the barbecue.
  • If using a propane cylinder with an electric starter, make sure the cylinder is not leaking and that all connections are tight before use.
  • Always use the appropriate amount of charcoal for your BBQ, as using too much can cause the coals to become too hot and potentially ignite the barbecue.
  • Once finished cooking, extinguish the coals and make sure they are completely cool before disposing of them in a metal container.

By following these safety measures, you can ensure that your BBQ is both enjoyable and safe. Remember, accidents can happen, so always be mindful of your surroundings and take necessary precautions to prevent injury or property damage.

Understood. Here is the Conclusion section for your article on chimney starters vs electric starters for charcoal barbecues:


After testing and analyzing both chimney and electric starters, it’s clear that they both have their pros and cons. To summarize, here are the key takeaways:

  • Speed: Electric starters are faster at heating up charcoal than chimney starters, but the difference in time is not significant.
  • Ease of use: Electric starters are more user-friendly and require minimal effort to use, while chimney starters require manual labor to heat up charcoal.
  • Price: Chimney starters are typically cheaper than electric starters.
  • Portability: Chimney starters are more portable and are great for camping and outdoor events where electricity is not readily available.
  • Flavor: Both methods produce similar flavors, but some users prefer the old-fashioned flavor that comes from chimney starters.

Ultimately, the decision between chimney and electric starters will depend on personal preference and specific needs. If you’re looking for a cost-effective, traditional option that doesn’t require electricity, a chimney starter might be the way to go. If you prefer a more convenient and user-friendly option, and don’t mind paying more, then an electric starter might suit your needs better.

Regardless of which method you choose, with a little practice and experimentation, you’ll quickly learn how to use your preferred starter to get your charcoal hot and ready for your next delicious barbecue.

Scroll to Top