Best Smokers for Turkey: Top Picks for Perfectly Cooked Thanksgiving Bird

Smoking a turkey is a time-honored tradition that many people look forward to every year. The process involves slow-cooking the turkey over low heat, which infuses it with smoky flavor and makes it incredibly juicy. However, not all smokers are created equal, and choosing the right one can make or break your turkey smoking experience.

When it comes to selecting the best smoker for turkey, there are a few critical things to consider. First and foremost, you want a smoker that can maintain a consistent temperature for an extended period. Smoking a turkey can take anywhere from 4 to 8 hours, so you need a smoker that can keep the temperature steady without requiring constant monitoring.

Another crucial factor to consider is the size of the smoker. You want a smoker that can comfortably accommodate a whole turkey without overcrowding it. Additionally, the smoker should be easy to use and clean, as smoking a turkey can be a messy process.

After researching and testing several smokers, we have identified the top options for smoking the perfect turkey. In the following sections, we will outline the features, pros, and cons of each smoker to help you make an informed decision.

Best Smokers for Turkey

We understand the importance of a perfectly smoked turkey for your Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner. That’s why we have compiled a list of the best smokers for turkey, so you can enjoy a succulent and juicy bird every time. Our team of experts has tested and reviewed various smokers based on factors such as temperature control, ease of use, and overall performance. Whether you are a beginner or a pro, we have options for everyone. So, without further ado, here are our top picks for the best smokers for turkey.

BMMXBI Turkey Hooks Accessories for Grilling

If you’re looking for a turkey hanger accessory for your Pit Barrel smoker, the BMMXBI Turkey Hooks Accessories for Grilling is a great option.

Pros

  • Perfect fit for Pit Barrel Junior/Classic/XL smokers
  • Made of food grade stainless steel material
  • Can cook a large turkey or two small turkeys at the same time

Cons

  • May not fit other types of smokers
  • May not be suitable for those who do not own a Pit Barrel smoker
  • Only includes one turkey fryer accessory

We recently used this turkey hanger accessory for our Thanksgiving dinner, and we were impressed with how well it cooked our turkey. The food grade stainless steel material felt sturdy and safe to use, and it was easy to clean after use. We were also able to cook a large turkey and a pan of vegetables at the same time, which added more flavor to our meal.

One potential downside is that this turkey hanger accessory may not fit other types of smokers, so it’s important to make sure it’s compatible with your smoker before purchasing. Additionally, it may not be suitable for those who do not own a Pit Barrel smoker. Lastly, it only includes one turkey fryer accessory, so if you plan to cook multiple turkeys at once, you may need to purchase additional accessories.

Overall, we highly recommend the BMMXBI Turkey Hooks Accessories for Grilling for those who own a Pit Barrel smoker and are looking for a reliable turkey hanger accessory.

ENLife Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element

If you’re looking for a reliable heating element for your electric smoker or grill, the ENLife Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element is a great option to consider.

Pros

  • Safe and high heating efficiency
  • Adjustable temperature range up to 550F
  • Fits many electric smokers and grills

Cons

  • Plastic end may not be durable
  • May not fit all devices, so make sure to confirm size before purchasing
  • Analog controller may not be as precise as digital options

We recently used the ENLife Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element for our turkey smoking needs and were impressed with its performance. The heating efficiency was high, and we were able to easily adjust the temperature to our desired level using the analog controller. However, we did notice that the plastic end may not be as durable as metal options, so it’s important to handle it with care.

It’s also worth noting that the ENLife Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element may not fit all devices, so make sure to confirm the size before purchasing. However, we found that it fit many electric smokers and grills with ease.

Overall, if you’re in need of a reliable heating element for your electric smoker or grill, the ENLife Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element is a solid choice to consider.

COMVIEE 1500 Watt Heating Element

If you’re in the market for a replacement heating element for your Masterbuilt Electric Analog Smoker, the COMVIEE 1500 Watt Heating Element is a solid choice that won’t break the bank.

Pros

  • The unique “ear” shape and surrounding heating wire layout make for better heating and more thorough wood chip burning, resulting in a better smoking effect and more flavorful BBQ.
  • The adjustable temperature range and easy-to-use thermostat cord controller make it easy to get the perfect temperature for your smoking needs.
  • The heating element is made of high-quality stainless steel and the temperature control power supply is made of durable soft rubber cables for long-lasting use.

Cons

  • Some customers have reported that the heating element did not reach the desired temperature after extended use, although this seems to be a rare occurrence.
  • The rectangular opening required for installation may not be compatible with all smokers and grills, so be sure to check before purchasing.
  • The customer service response time may be slower than expected, so keep that in mind if you have any issues.

We recently used the COMVIEE 1500 Watt Heating Element in our Masterbuilt Electric Analog Smoker and were pleased with the results. The “ear” shape and heating wire layout did indeed result in a better smoking effect and more flavorful BBQ. The adjustable temperature range and thermostat cord controller made it easy to get the perfect temperature for our smoking needs.

While we did not experience any issues with the heating element reaching the desired temperature, we did notice that the rectangular opening required for installation may not be compatible with all smokers and grills. Additionally, some customers have reported slower than expected response times from customer service.

Overall, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly replacement heating element for your Masterbuilt Electric Analog Smoker, the COMVIEE 1500 Watt Heating Element is a solid choice. Just be sure to double-check compatibility before purchasing.

Unidanho Power Cord for Masterbuilt Smoker – Replacement Power Cord with Thermostat Control for Masterbuilt Electric Smokers and Turkey Fryers(1250, 15A)

If you’re looking for a replacement power cord for your Masterbuilt smoker, the Unidanho Power Cord with Thermostat Control might be the perfect solution.

Pros

  • Wide compatibility with most electric smokers and grill heating elements
  • High-quality replacement part that will last for years
  • Precise temperature control ensures your meat is cooked to perfection every time

Cons

  • No temperature control, only on/off switch
  • Some users have reported stiffness when plugging in the cord
  • Some users have reported poor quality for the price paid

We recently tested the Unidanho Power Cord with Thermostat Control and were impressed with its wide compatibility and easy installation. The 5.9 ft cord is long enough for most setups and the high-quality materials ensure it will last for years.

The precise temperature control is a game-changer for any serious smoker, ensuring that your meat is cooked to perfection every time. However, it’s important to note that there is no temperature control, only an on/off switch.

Some users have reported stiffness when plugging in the cord, but we didn’t experience this issue during our testing. Additionally, some users have reported poor quality for the price paid, but we found the Unidanho Power Cord to be a great value for its functionality.

Overall, if you’re in need of a replacement power cord for your Masterbuilt smoker, the Unidanho Power Cord with Thermostat Control is a solid choice.

KILILIUN Universal Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element Replacement Part with Adjustable Thermostat Cord Controlle for Masterbuilt Smokers & Turkey Fryers 1500 Watts

If you’re looking for a reliable and efficient heating element replacement for your smoker, the KILILIUN Universal Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element is definitely worth considering.

Pros

  • The ear-shaped curved design of the heating line allows for better burning of wood chips and better smoking effect.
  • The heating element is made of high quality stainless steel, which is more wear-resistant and reduces the cost of product replacement.
  • The temperature control power supply is made of high quality flexible rubber cable, which greatly improves safety when using.

Cons

  • The adjustable temperature range depends on the size of the smoker/grill and the amount of food you put in. It’s important to confirm the temperature range before purchasing.
  • The product is only compatible with certain Masterbuilt models. If you’re unsure whether your model matches the product, you should contact the manufacturer.
  • Some modifications may be necessary to fit the heating element into your smoker.

We recently tried out this heating element replacement and were impressed with its performance. The ear-shaped design truly does help with the smoking effect and the high quality materials make it a durable option for long-term use.

Installation was fairly easy, although we did need to make some modifications to our smoker to fit the element properly. However, once installed, the temperature control was accurate and reliable. We also appreciated the two-year warranty and return service offered by the manufacturer.

Overall, we would recommend the KILILIUN Universal Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element Replacement Part to anyone in need of a reliable and efficient heating element replacement for their smoker. Just make sure to confirm compatibility and temperature range before purchasing.

Captiva Designs 18-inch Vertical Charcoal Smoker Grill

If you’re looking for a versatile smoker that can smoke and grill meats, the Captiva Designs 18-inch Vertical Charcoal Smoker Grill might be for you.

Pros

  • The porcelain-enameled smoking chamber helps control temperature and is rust-resistant, anti-peeling, and easy to clean.
  • The modular stacking design allows this smoker to be easily converted into a charcoal grill for multi-functional use.
  • The two adjustable levels of cooking area and fully enamel water bowl provide flexibility and moist heat for tender meat.

Cons

  • The smoker is not the sturdiest and may wear out over time with frequent use.
  • Some customers have reported missing parts or issues with the lid not securing properly.
  • The smoker may require frequent adjustments to maintain temperature and smoke levels.

In our experience, the Captiva Designs 18-inch Vertical Charcoal Smoker Grill is a decent option for those who want a smoker that can also be used as a grill. The porcelain-enameled smoking chamber is a great feature that helps control temperature and makes cleaning easier. However, the smoker may not be the most durable option and may require frequent adjustments to maintain temperature. Overall, it’s a good choice for those who want a versatile smoker but don’t want to break the bank.

WADEO Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element Replacement Part

If you’re looking for a replacement heating element for your smoker or grill, the WADEO Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element Replacement Part is definitely worth considering.

Pros

  • The ear shape design allows wood chips to burn more fully and smoke better.
  • It is made of high-quality stainless steel, and the temperature control power is made of superior flexible rubber cable.
  • It is suitable for most smokers and grill heating elements on the market.

Cons

  • It does not heat up to the advertised temperature.
  • Some customers received damaged products due to poor packaging.
  • The rectangular opening may not fit all smokers and grills.

We recently used the WADEO Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element Replacement Part to replace the heating element in our Masterbuilt smoker. The ear shape design did indeed allow the wood chips to burn more fully and smoke better, resulting in a more flavorful turkey. The high-quality stainless steel material ensured durability, and the flexible rubber cable made it easy to adjust the temperature.

However, we did notice that it did not heat up to the advertised temperature. It was also disappointing to see that some customers received damaged products due to poor packaging. Additionally, the rectangular opening may not fit all smokers and grills, so make sure to check the dimensions before purchasing.

Overall, if you’re looking for a replacement heating element for your smoker or grill, the WADEO Electric Smoker and Grill Heating Element Replacement Part is a decent option. Just make sure to double-check the dimensions and be aware of the potential heating issues.

AJinTeby Electric Smoker Universal Replacement Part

If you’re looking for a replacement heating element for your electric smoker or grill, the AJinTeby 1500W Grill Heating Element with Adjustable Thermostat Cord Controller is a great option to consider.

Pros

  • Easy to install with an adjustable mounting bracket and support feet
  • Compatible with a variety of smokers and grills, including Masterbuilt, Smoke Hollow, Char Broil, Brinkman, and Royal Gourmet SE2801 Electric Smoker
  • Features an adjustable thermostat cord controller to adjust temperature from 50 F up to 450 F

Cons

  • Some users reported issues with the temperature control accuracy
  • The heating element may not fit all smoker models, so check the dimensions before purchasing
  • The cord length may be too short for some setups

We found this heating element to be a reliable replacement part for electric smokers and grills. The adjustable mounting bracket and support feet make it easy to install, and the adjustable thermostat cord controller allows for precise temperature control.

However, some users reported issues with the temperature control accuracy, so you may need to keep an eye on the temperature to ensure it stays at the desired level. Additionally, the heating element may not fit all smoker models, so be sure to check the dimensions before purchasing.

Overall, if you’re looking for a replacement heating element for your electric smoker or grill, the AJinTeby 1500W Grill Heating Element with Adjustable Thermostat Cord Controller is a solid choice to consider.

Buying Guide

When it comes to buying a smoker for turkey, there are a few key features to consider to ensure you get the best product for your needs. Here are some factors to keep in mind:

Type of Smoker

There are several types of smokers available on the market, including electric, propane, charcoal, and wood pellet smokers. Each type has its own benefits and drawbacks, so it’s important to choose the one that best suits your preferences and cooking style.

Cooking Space

The cooking space is another important factor to consider when choosing a smoker. If you’re planning on cooking large turkeys or multiple birds at once, you’ll need a smoker with a larger cooking space. On the other hand, if you’re only cooking for a small group, a smaller smoker may be sufficient.

Temperature Control

Temperature control is crucial when smoking turkey, as it ensures that the meat is cooked to perfection. Look for a smoker with accurate temperature control and the ability to maintain a consistent temperature throughout the cooking process.

Durability

A smoker is an investment, so it’s important to choose a product that is built to last. Look for a smoker made from high-quality materials that can withstand the elements and frequent use.

Additional Features

Finally, consider any additional features that may be important to you, such as built-in thermometers, easy-to-clean grates, and adjustable racks. These features can make the smoking process more convenient and enjoyable.

By keeping these factors in mind, you can choose a smoker that will help you create delicious, perfectly smoked turkey every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do we smoke a turkey breast to ensure it stays moist?

Smoking a turkey breast can be a challenge as it tends to dry out quickly. To keep it moist, we recommend brining the turkey breast before smoking. You can also inject it with a marinade to add flavor and moisture. Smoking at a lower temperature and basting the turkey breast with butter or oil can also help keep it moist.

What are the steps to smoking a turkey in a Traeger smoker?

To smoke a turkey in a Traeger smoker, start by preheating the smoker to 225°F. Rub the turkey with your desired seasoning and place it on the grill. Smoke the turkey until it reaches an internal temperature of 165°F, which should take about 3-4 hours for a 12-14 pound turkey. Let the turkey rest for 15-20 minutes before carving.

Can you provide guidance on using a Pit Boss smoker for turkey?

To smoke a turkey in a Pit Boss smoker, start by preheating the smoker to 225°F. Place the turkey on the grill and smoke until it reaches an internal temperature of 165°F, which should take about 3-4 hours for a 12-14 pound turkey. Baste the turkey with butter or oil every hour to keep it moist. Let the turkey rest for 15-20 minutes before carving.

What is the ideal temperature for smoking a turkey to achieve the best flavor?

The ideal temperature for smoking a turkey is between 225°F and 250°F. This allows the turkey to cook slowly and absorb the smoky flavor without drying out. It is important to monitor the temperature throughout the smoking process to ensure the turkey is cooked to perfection.

How long should a 20lb turkey be smoked in an electric smoker?

A 20lb turkey should be smoked in an electric smoker for about 6-7 hours at 225°F. It is important to check the internal temperature of the turkey with a meat thermometer to ensure it has reached 165°F before removing it from the smoker.

What techniques can be used to get crispy skin on a smoked turkey?

To get crispy skin on a smoked turkey, we recommend rubbing the turkey with oil or butter before smoking. You can also finish the turkey in the oven at a high temperature for the last 10-15 minutes of cooking to crisp up the skin. Another technique is to place the turkey in a roasting pan and broil it for a few minutes to achieve a crispy skin.

Scroll to Top