Best Pit Boss Alternatives for Top-Notch Grilling in 2024

Smokers and grills have taken the cooking world by storm. They let us cook delicious meats and veggies with that unmistakable smoky flavor. Pit Boss smokers are known for their quality and variety, but they aren’t the only choice out there. There are several alternatives that might better fit our needs or budgets.

When we’re looking to purchase a smoker, there are a few important things to consider. First, think about the fuel type: pellet, gas, charcoal, or electric. Each has its unique benefits and drawbacks. Also, pay attention to the size. We want to make sure the smoker fits in our backyard and can cook enough food for our gatherings. Temperature control is another critical factor. The easier it is to maintain a steady temperature, the better our food will turn out.

We spent countless hours researching and testing different smokers to identify the best Pit Boss alternatives.

Best Pit Boss Alternatives

We’ve rounded up some top alternatives to Pit Boss for grilling and smoking. Let’s check out these great options to help spark your next barbecue adventure.

Pit Boss 10537 Wood Pellet Grill

This grill is perfect for anyone who loves outdoor cooking and wants versatile functionality.


  • Easy to assemble and start up
  • Reliable heat maintenance
  • Large cooking capacity


  • Temperature can fluctuate
  • Not completely weatherproof
  • Some assembly issues

We recently spent a weekend cooking on the Pit Boss 10537 Wood Pellet Grill, and it was quite a treat. One thing we noticed right away was how easy it was to put together. It took us less than an hour, and before we knew it, we were ready to start cooking.

Once we fired it up, the grill heated evenly and held the temperature well. We tried grilling, smoking, and even baking, and everything turned out delicious. The large cooking area is also a huge plus, letting us prepare multiple dishes at once without any hassle.

That said, the temperature did fluctuate slightly now and then, which can be a bit tricky if you’re smoking meat over long periods. Additionally, it’s important to cover and keep it dry because it isn’t fully weatherproof. Despite a minor issue with a damaged leg during shipping, which we easily fixed, our overall experience was positive.

For anyone considering this grill, it offers great value with its ease of use and versatility. Just take a little extra care to maintain it, and it should serve you well for many years of delicious grilling.

XANGNIER Silicone Drip Bucket Liners

An excellent investment for anyone looking to switch from disposable to reusable grill accessories.


  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Easy to clean and reuse
  • Space-saving folding design


  • Can be a bit messy during cleaning
  • May not fit all grill models
  • Higher initial cost compared to disposables

We had the chance to try out the XANGNIER Silicone Drip Bucket Liners, and we were quite impressed. These liners fit snugly into most grease buckets, attaching perfectly to grills like the Traeger, Pit Boss, and more. The foldable design makes them easy to store, which is a real bonus for those of us with limited space.

One of the standout features is their durability. Unlike disposable aluminum liners, these silicone ones are built to last. We found them incredibly easy to remove and clean, thanks to the handy double handle design. You can just rinse them off or toss them in the dishwasher.

While they are more expensive upfront than disposable liners, the long-term savings are substantial. Plus, they’re environmentally friendly, helping reduce waste. If you grill a lot and hate the hassle of replacing liners, these might be the perfect solution.

Pit Boss 3-In-1 Burger Press

A must-have tool for anyone wanting perfectly shaped burgers with minimal effort.


  • It’s versatile for making burgers, sliders, and stuffed patties.
  • BPA-free plastic ensures the patty won’t stick.
  • Easy cleanup thanks to the non-stick surface.


  • May not be large enough for some preferences.
  • Lacks clear instructions for all features.
  • The press can feel greasy during use.

The Pit Boss 3-In-1 Burger Press is a nifty gadget for burger lovers. We’ve had a blast using this to create all sorts of burger variations. From sliders to stuffed patties, this press does it all. Each patty comes out perfectly shaped, which is great when you’re hosting a BBQ and want everything to look consistent.

One thing we noticed is the size might not suit everyone’s tastes. If you’re someone who enjoys large, hearty burgers, this press might feel a bit small. There’s also a bit of a learning curve, especially when trying to figure out how to make the sliders and stuffed patties just right. We ended up searching online videos for help.

Cleaning up afterward is a breeze, though. The non-stick plastic means you won’t have meat sticking everywhere, and it’s safe to throw in the dishwasher. Despite some minor hassles, it’s a handy tool that definitely adds some fun to burger night.

FlameDuty Grill Grate

This grill grate is a reliable, high-quality alternative for anyone looking to replace their Pit Boss grill grate.


  • Great fit for various grills
  • Leaves excellent sear marks
  • Heavy-duty and durable


  • A bit heavy to handle
  • Needs regular maintenance to prevent rusting
  • Limited availability

We decided to try out the FlameDuty Grill Grate because our original grate was starting to show its age. The first thing we noticed was how perfectly it fit our grill. It’s designed for a variety of models, and the sturdy construction immediately stood out.

Grilling with this grate is a dream. It holds heat exceptionally well and leaves those beautiful sear marks on steaks and veggies. Cleaning it is a breeze, just a quick wipe, and it’s as good as new.

Though it’s a bit on the heavy side, this only adds to its durability. If you’re looking for a dependable replacement grate that can handle lots of grilling, FlameDuty Grill Grate is worth considering.

QuliMetal Grill Cover

If you’re seeking a durable grill cover that can withstand various weather conditions, this one is a great choice.


  • Strong and weather-resistant
  • Easy to install and remove
  • Reflective tape for visibility


  • May leave some legs exposed
  • Thin fabric may not be very long-lasting
  • Lacks side tray compatibility

This cover is built to last, thanks to its heavy-duty 600D fabric. We’ve found it to be incredibly resistant to water, sun, and even heavy winds. With side handles, it’s simple to fit or remove, making our lives easier when it comes to grilling.

We also love the reflective tape feature. It helps us spot the grill in low light conditions, which adds a layer of safety. The air vents are great for reducing moisture buildup, preventing rust over time.

However, we did notice that the cover might be slightly short, exposing some of the legs. This might not be a huge deal for most, but it’s worth mentioning. The fabric, while durable, feels a bit thin and may not stand the test of time.

Overall, this grill cover offers a good balance of features and price. It’s easy to use and maintains the quality of our grill through various weather conditions. The pros definitely outweigh the cons in our experience.


This is an excellent grill cover for those looking for a sturdy and reliable alternative to Pit Boss.


  • Fits various Pit Boss models perfectly
  • Convenient front zipper design
  • High-quality waterproof material


  • May require additional securing in high winds
  • Does not fit Pit Boss 700 models snugly
  • Drawstring might loosen over time

The SHINESTAR Grill Cover impressed us with its perfect fit for many Pit Boss models. We loved how the front zipper made it much easier to put on and take off. This feature saved us a lot of effort, especially after grilling sessions.

The heavy-duty fabric felt durable, and the cover’s waterproof capability kept our grill dry even during heavy rain. The quality of the material suggests it should withstand various weather conditions. What made it even better was the anti-UV coating, which prevented fading.

However, in strong winds, we did notice the need for extra securing to ensure the cover stayed put. A bungee cord solved this problem quickly. While it fit our Pit Boss 820 Series perfectly, it was somewhat loose on our Pit Boss 700, which was a bit disappointing. Also, the drawstring can be tricky, as it has a tendency to loosen over time.

Overall, the SHINESTAR Grill Cover is a solid choice for keeping your grill protected year-round.

DRELD 6 Feet Smoker Power Cord Kit

This power cord kit is a solid choice for replacing damaged cords on Pit Boss and Traeger pellet grills.


  • Easy to install
  • Durable and flexible cables
  • High-quality construction


  • Installation space can be tight
  • Not an exact match for all models
  • May need to splice wires

We recently tried out the DRELD 6 Feet Smoker Power Cord Kit on our custom Pit Boss grill, and it worked just like the original. The installation was straightforward, thanks to the easy splicing to thermostat leads. The high-quality construction made us feel confident in its durability.

The cable was indeed flexible, which made it easier to maneuver around the tight compartments of the grill. There’s a satisfaction in knowing it can handle more wear and tear than our old one. Plus, being waterproof adds another layer of reliability.

One issue we noticed was that the installation space was a bit tight. While it wasn’t a major problem, it did require some patience. Despite this, the final fit was secure and functional. This is a great replacement cord, and we highly recommend it for anyone needing a sturdy and reliable fix.

GRISUN Round Grill Grate

If you’re looking for a durable, versatile grill grate that fits many popular grills, this might be the one for you.


  • Great for professional sear marks
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • High-quality stainless steel


  • Might not fit all grill models perfectly
  • Can be pricey compared to other options
  • Some users report it slipping off the grill if not careful

Cooking on the GRISUN Round Grill Grate was a breeze. The 304 stainless steel material is very sturdy and resistant to rust, which means it’ll last a long time. We love how it leaves those professional sear marks on our steaks and burgers, making them look as good as they taste.

One of the best features is the flip-up design. It makes adding charcoal super easy without having to remove the whole grate, saving us a lot of time and hassle. Plus, the 1-inch hole allows for a warming rack, which is perfect for keeping food warm while we finish grilling the rest.

Cleaning this grate is no problem at all. The smooth surface makes it easy to wipe down with some soapy water. Just be cautious when fitting it to your grill; since it’s designed to fit multiple models, it might not be a perfect fit for all. Some users have noted it can slip if not placed correctly. Despite this, the quality and convenience make it a solid choice for anyone serious about grilling.

Buying Guide

When we’re looking for the best pit boss alternatives, there are a few key things to keep in mind.


It’s important to set a budget. Grills can range from affordable to high-end. We should think about how often we’ll use it and what features are worth paying extra for.


How much space do we have? If we have a small patio, a compact grill might be best. For bigger backyards, we can go for larger models that can cook more food at once.

Fuel Type

  • Gas Grills: Quick and easy to use. Great for weeknight dinners.
  • Charcoal Grills: Famous for smoky flavor but require more time to heat up.
  • Electric Grills: Ideal for indoor use but might lack the traditional flavor.

Cooking Surface

We should look at the material of the cooking surface. Cast iron is durable, but stainless steel is easy to clean. Also, consider the size of the cooking area.

Extra Features

Some grills come with extra features that can make cooking easier and more enjoyable:

  • Side Burners: Perfect for cooking side dishes.
  • Rotisserie: Great for evenly cooked meats.
  • Temperature Gauges: Helps us keep an eye on the heat.


If we’re planning to take our grill camping or tailgating, a portable model is a must. Lightweight and foldable options can fit easily into our car.

Ease of Cleaning

Nobody likes cleaning up, so it’s smart to check how easy the grill is to clean. Removable drip trays and porcelain-coated grates can make this task much simpler.

This buying guide should help us make an informed choice when picking out our next grill. Happy grilling!

Scroll to Top